How do I recover pumper shortages fairly?
For owners, station managers · By the Petro team · Last reviewed
The short answer
Check every shortage with the pumper before treating it as theirs, because many turn out to be recording mistakes. Agree in writing, before it happens, how confirmed shortages are settled, and record each one against the pumper with excesses counted too. What may be deducted from wages is set by Sri Lankan labour law and the employment contract, so check both, and take advice, before deducting anything from a salary.
Why does fairness matter here?
Pumpers handle large amounts of cash on low wages. A shortage charged without checking, or recovered in a way that comes as a surprise, damages trust quickly and costs you good staff. A clear, fair process does the opposite: honest staff are protected, the figures are trusted, and anyone who is careless or dishonest stands out.
What should I check before treating a shortage as the pumper's?
- That the opening and closing meter readings are right, and the opening is the previous shift's closing.
- That every credit bill, card slip, QR payment and test was recorded against the right pumper and pump.
- That every cash drop was counted against them.
- That the price used was right for the whole shift, including any price change.
- That the cash was counted with the pumper present.
Only a shortage that is still there after these checks, and that the pumper has seen and signed, should be treated as theirs.
How should shortages be recorded?
Record every confirmed shortage against the pumper, with the date, the shift, the pump, the amount and their signature. Record excesses the same way. Keeping a running balance per pumper, rather than a separate charge for each shift, lets an excess on one day offset a shortage on another, which is fairer and usually closer to what really happened.
How can a shortage be settled?
- Paid back in cash by the pumper, with a receipt, which keeps it separate from wages.
- Carried on their account and settled over time by agreement, so a single bad shift does not take a large part of one month's pay.
- Recovered from wages, only where Sri Lankan labour law and the pumper's employment contract allow it, and in the way they allow. Check both before doing it, and keep the pumper's written agreement.
- Written off, for a small amount the pumper could not reasonably have prevented, such as a counterfeit note found later.
The rules on deductions from wages depend on the law that covers the employee and the terms of their contract. Read the contract, check the current law with the Department of Labour or a qualified adviser, and make sure the station's written rule on shortages fits both.
What should the station's written rule say?
- How cash is counted at the end of each shift, and that the pumper is present.
- How a shortage is checked before it is confirmed, and how the pumper can question it.
- That excesses are recorded and count against shortages.
- How confirmed shortages are settled, and over what period.
- What happens when shortages keep repeating, and who decides.
Explain it to every pumper when they join, give them a copy in a language they read, and keep their signed copy. Apply it the same way to everyone.
Frequently asked questions
- Should shortages be settled every shift or every month?
- Confirm and record them every shift, while everyone remembers what happened. Settle them over a longer period, such as a month, using the running balance, so excesses are counted and small differences can even out.
- What if a pumper refuses to sign a shortage?
- Go through the figures again with them and a witness. If you still disagree, record the shortage as disputed with both views and the evidence, and settle it later through your agreed process rather than deducting it anyway.
- Can I deduct a shortage from a salary without asking?
- Do not assume you can. Whether a deduction is allowed, and how much, depends on Sri Lankan labour law and the employment contract. Check both, take advice, and have the pumper's written agreement before deducting anything.
- What if the same pumper is short again and again?
- Look at the pattern first: the pump, the shift and the other people on duty. If the shortages follow the pumper wherever they work, discuss it with them openly, offer extra training on counting and recording, and keep closer checks for a while. If it continues, follow your written rule and take advice before any disciplinary step.
How Petro handles this
In Petro a shortage left on a pumper's shift invoice can be closed and carried on the pumper's own account with Make Payment on Account, and an excess is recorded as an Excess Payment owed to the pumper. The Pumper Report shows every pumper's outstanding balance until it is settled, and the Short Excess Report and Pumper Payment on Account Report show the shortages, excesses and repayments per pumper, for review before payroll.
See Petro's reportsOfficial sources
This guide is general information for Sri Lankan fuel stations, written by the Petro team. Figures in examples are made up. For a decision about your own tax or legal position, check with your accountant or the authority named in the sources.
